Sell Us Your Cards!
Turn the cards you are no longer using into cash or store credit at Unplugged Gaming!
We buy Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon Trading Card Game collections of all sizes, from a handful of valuable cards to entire binders, decks, sealed products, and large collections.
What We Buy
Magic: The Gathering
We are interested in:
- Singles
- Commander Staples
- Competitive Cards
- Reserved List Cards
- Foils & Special Treatments
- Sealed Products
- Bulk Collections
Pokémon TCG
We are interested in:
- Modern & Vintage Singles
- Illustration Rares & Special Illustration Rares
- Full Arts & Secret Rares
- Vintage Holos
- Graded Cards
- Sealed Products
- Complete Binders & Collections
Other Games We Buy
We also purchase singles from the following trading card games:
Please note: We currently purchase cards from these games only if they have a value of $5.00 or more per card and are in Near Mint (NM) condition.
Why Sell to Unplugged Gaming?
Fast and Convenient
Skip the work of photographing, listing, shipping, and dealing with individual buyers. Bring your cards to the store and let our team handle the rest.
Fair Offers
Our offers are based on current values, card condition, demand, and the size of the collection.
Cash or Store Credit
Choose the option that works best for you. Store credit offers may receive a higher value than cash offers.
Local and Trusted
Work directly with the team at Unplugged Gaming. Your cards stay local and help support the gaming community you already know.
How It Works
Stop by Unplugged Gaming with the cards or collection you are interested in selling.
Our team will evaluate the cards based on condition, value, and demand.
Once the evaluation is complete, we will provide you with an offer for cash or store credit.
Accept or decline the offer and complete the sale. It's that simple!
Selling a Large Collection?
For large, valuable, or inherited collections, we recommend contacting us before visiting. This allows us to make sure the appropriate staff member is available and that we have enough time to properly review everything.
Depending on the size of your collection, you may be asked to leave it with us for a period of time while our team carefully sorts, identifies, and prices every card. This helps ensure your collection receives the attention it deserves and allows us to provide the most accurate offer possible.
To help us evaluate your collection more efficiently, please provide:
- Approximate number of cards
- Games included in the collection
- Photos of binders or valuable cards
- Any available inventory lists
- Whether the collection includes sealed or graded products
Help Us Maximize Your Offer
The more organized your collection is, the more efficiently we can process it.
If cards need to be removed from binders, penny sleeves, top loaders, or other storage before they can be sorted and evaluated, a processing fee based on a percentage of the collection's value may apply to cover the additional labor involved.
For the best possible offer, we recommend bringing your cards organized by game, set, or rarity whenever possible. Well-organized collections take less time to process, allowing us to return more value directly to you.
Get Started
Have Magic or Pokémon cards you are ready to sell?
Bring them to Unplugged Gaming or contact us today to discuss your collection.
spidr@unpluggedgamestore.com
Phone: 315-632-5034
You may also contact us on our Discord and open a ticket if you have any further questions.
All purchases are subject to inspection and approval. Offers may vary based on card condition, authenticity, demand, available inventory, and current market value. Unplugged Gaming reserves the right to decline any card or collection.
